American Idol: The Top 4

Who do you think will win, whether they deserve it or not?

Kimberley Locke

Ruben

Josh

Clay

Who should have been voted off Tuesday?

Why did Josh make it this far?

He's in the military

America is Racist

He has talent

He was lucky

All of the above

None of the above

Why did Kimberley make it this far?

She has a great voice

She has the whole package

Luck

She dissed Simon

None of the above

Why did Ruben make it this far?

He has a great voice

He looks like a teddy bear

He has a good attitude

He is the American Idol

Luck

All of these

Why did Trenyce get voted off?

She wasn't as good

America is racist

No reason at all

Bad Luck

How much do the judges influence the vote?

Completely

A lot

Somewhat

Not at all

Who should have been in the top 12?