What went down in AMERICAN IDOL II?

Here you can vote for the weekly performances, and say who YOU thought should have been in the Bottom 3 each week. Also, there will be some questions on style about each contestant!

Alright, the real winner, Ruben Studdard was chosen as the next American Idol. Who really should have been the last guy standing?

Clay Aiken

Josh Gracin

Rickey Smith

Corey Clark

Charles Grigsby

America got it right- Ruben Studdard

Who should have been the last woman standing in competition?

Trenyce

Carmen Rasmusen

Kimberly Caldwell

Julia DeMato

Vanessa Olivarez

America got it right - Kimberley Locke

Choose the bottom three for "Motown Week," judging on who had the weakest performance that night. Only choose three.

Choose the bottom 3 for "Movie Soundtrack Songs," judging on who had the weakest performance. Only choose 3!

Choose the bottom three for "Country Rock songs," judging on who had the weakest performance.

Choose the bottom 3 for "Disco" night, judging on who had the weakest performance.

Rickey Smith "Let's Groove"

Kimberly Caldwell "Knock on Wood"

Carmen Rasmusen "Turn the Beat Around"

Trenyce "I'm Every Woman"

Josh Gracin "Celebration"

Kimberley Locke "It's Raining Men"

Clay Aiken "Everlasting Love"

Ruben Studdard "Can't Get Enough of your Love"

Choose your bottom 3 for "Billboard's #1 Hits" remembering who had the worst vocals and the worst stage presence, too!

Rickey Smith "Endless Love"

Kimberly Caldwell "Everything I Do (I Do it For You)"

Carmen Rasmusen "Call Me"

Trenyce "The Power of Love"

Josh Gracin "Amazed"

Kimberley Locke "My Heart Will Go On"

Clay Aiken "At This Moment"

Ruben Studdard "Kiss, and Say Goodbye"

Choose the BOTTOM THREE for the Billy Joel performances, which 3 were the weakest?

Kimberly Caldwell "It's Still Rock-n-Roll to Me"

Carmen Rasmusen "And So it Goes"

Trenyce "Baby Grand"

Josh Gracin "Piano Man"

Kimberley Locke "New York State of Mind"

Clay Aiken "Tell Her About It"

Ruben Studdard "Just the Way You Are"

Who is your bottom three for Diane Warren songs? Click three of the following choices for the worst performances of the night.

Carmen Rasmusen "Love Will Lead You Back"

Trenyce "Have You Ever?"

Josh Gracin "That's When I'll Stop Loving You"

Kimberley Locke "If You Asked Me To"

Clay Aiken "I Could Not Ask for More"

Ruben Studdard "Music of My Heart"

Who would be in the bottom three for the double song night, NEIL SADAKA and THE 60S? Which three of the 5 were the worst

Trenyce "Love Will Keep Us Together" and "Proud Mary"

Josh Gracin "Then You Could Tell me Goodbye" and "Bad Blood"

Kimberley Locke "I Heard it Through the Grapevine" and "Where the Boys Are"

Clay Aiken "Build Me Up Buttercup" and "Solitaire"

Ruben Studdard "Ain't too Proud to Beg" and "Breaking Up is Hard to Do"

Who would the bottom TWO be for the two BeeGee songs? Choose only 2 of the following, checking the worst ones.

Josh Gracin "Jive Talkin'" and "To Love Somebody"

Kimberley Locke "Emotion" and "I Just Want to be Your Everything"

Clay Aiken "Grease" and "To Love Somebody"

Ruben Studdard "Nights on Broadway" and "Mend a Broken Heart"

When it comes down to who made it in the BOTTOM THREE, who do you think SHOULD have been the FINAL TWO STANDING in the competition?

Clay Aiken and Ruben Studdard

Ruben Studdard and Kimberley Locke

Kimberley Locke and Clay Aiken

Who do you think the judges mis-judged weekly?

Ruben Studdard - he was not as flawless and perfect each week like the judges made him out to be

Carmen Rasmusen - she was not as horrible at all, and was even better than some

Julia DeMato - was better than the judges have said and she should have stayed around longer

Vanessa Olivarez - a very talented singer, she deserved more of a chance

Which contestant would you want to spend a day in New York with, go shopping, and out to dinner with? Who would it be the most fun with?

Of the ladies, who had the best style and owned the stage the best?

Julia DeMato

Kimberly Caldwell

Carmen Rasmusen

Trenyce

Kimberley Locke

Vanessa Olivarez

Of all the guys, which one owned the stage the best each and every week?

Which performance was one of the best performances of the entire competition?

Carmen Rasmusen "You Can't Hurry Love"

Trenyce "Proud Mary"

Josh Gracin "Piano Man"

Kimberley Locke "New York State of Mind"

Clay Aiken "Solitaire"

Clay Aiken "Build Me Up Buttercup"

Ruben Studdard "Sweet Home Alabama"

Which performance could have been a lot better and was perhaps one of the worst performances?

This poll was created on 2003-09-16 21:15:14 by BrettBud