Welcome! Sign in to access your account. New user?

Judicial Corporal Punishment

Results | Messages
Nowadays, most of the countries prohibits to use of corporal punishment as a form of judicial punishment. This poll serves to gather people opinions about possible reintroduction of corporal punishment in modern legal system.
What is your gender?
Male
Female
Other
What is your age?
Below 13
13-18
18-25
26-35
36-44
45-59
60+
And where are you from?
Western or Central Europe
Eastern Europe
North America
South America
Middle East
Far East
Africa
Australia
Other
Do you think that judicial corporal punishment (JCP) should be reintroduced in modern legal system?
Yes.
No.
Which of the offences listed below should result in JCP?
Minor and non-violent offences (eg. vandalism, destruction of property, disturbance of public order).
Violent minor offences (eg. street fight without causing injury).
Traffic offences (eg. speeding).
Petty crimes (eg. pilfering, pickpocketing).
Serious but non-violent crimes (eg. theft, embezzlement, fraud).
Violent serious crimes (eg. rape, murder).
There should be no JCP at all.
What social groups, in your opinion, could be convicted to JCP.
Adult males.
Juvenile males.
Adult females.
Juvenile females.
No one should be convicted to JCP.
What should be the minimum age to order a JCP for juvenile offender?
17
16
15
14
13
12
11
10
9
8
7
6 and less
I think juvenile offenders should not be sentenced to JCP.
Where the JCP should be administred?
In prisons only (even if the offender is not convicted to prison time he/she must go to prison only to be punished and is released immediately after execution).
In prisons, but not only.
In courts (rooms created specially for this).
In police stations (rooms created specially for this).
In special institution (corporal punishment centres).
Other places, please describe them...
Nowhere, there should be no JCP at all.
What do you think about public administration of JCP?
There should be no public JCP at all.
Public JCP should be reserved for serious offences.
Public JCP should be reserved for recidivists.
Public JCP could be ordered in any (even minor) case if the judge will find it appropriate.
All JCP should be administered in public.
It could be reserved for adult offenders only.
It could be reserved for juvenile offenders only.
There should be no JCP at all.
What form of JCP could be used on adult offenders?
Bare back whipping.
Clothed back whipping.
Bare buttocks lashing.
Clothed buttocks lashing.
Other forms of JCP.
There should be no JCP of adult offenders.
What implements could be used on adult offenders?
Cane.
Birch.
Strap.
Tawse.
Paddle.
Single tail whip.
Cat o' nine tails.
Other.
There should be no JCP of adult offenders.
How an adult offender should present for JCP?
Fully clothed.
Naked from the waist down.
Naked from the waist up.
Only genitals covered.
Completely nude.
Other.
There should be no JCP of adult offenders.
What form of JCP could be used on juvenile offenders?
Bare back whipping.
Clothed back whipping.
Bare buttocks lashing.
Clothed buttocks lashing.
Other forms of JCP.
There should be no JCP of juvenile offenders.
What implements could be used on juvenile offenders?
Cane.
Birch.
Strap.
Tawse.
Paddle.
Single tail whip.
Cat o' nine tails.
Other.
There should be no JCP of juvenile offenders.
How an juvenile offender should present for JCP?
Fully clothed.
Naked from the waist down (buttocks lashing).
Naked from the waist up (back whipping).
Only genitals covered.
Completely nude.
Other.
There should be no JCP of juvenile offenders.
What do you think about voluntary submission to JCP in some cases?
Offenders of all ages should have an option to voluntarily submit to JCP instead of fines or imprisonment.
Adult offenders should have an option to voluntarily submit to JCP instead of fines or imprisonment.
Juvenile offenders should have an option to voluntarily submit to JCP instead of fines or imprisonment.
No one should have an option to voluntarily submit to JCP instead of fines or imprisonment.
There should be no JCP at all.
Case #1: A 44 years old woman was found guilty of driving under the influence of alcohol. Which of the following is the most appropriate punishment?
Imprisonment for 6 months only.
Imprisonment for 3 months only.
Imprisonment for 3 months + 20 strokes on naked buttocks.
Imprisonment for 4 weeks + 50 strokes on naked buttocks.
Imprisonment for 4 weeks + 20 strokes on naked buttocks.
50 strokes on naked buttocks only.
20 strokes on naked buttocks only.
Other form of punishment.
Case #2: A 26 years old man was found guilty of shoplifting (stole a smartphone). Which of the following is the most appropriate punishment?
Imprisonment for 6 months only.
Imprisonment for 3 months only.
Imprisonment for 3 months + 20 strokes on naked buttocks.
Imprisonment for 4 weeks + 50 strokes on naked buttocks.
Imprisonment for 4 weeks + 20 strokes on naked buttocks.
50 strokes on naked buttocks only.
20 strokes on naked buttocks only.
Other form of punishment.
Case #3: A 16 years old girl was found guilty of underage drinking of alcohol and disturbance of peace. Which of the following is the most appropriate punishment?
30 hours of community work only.
20 hours of community work only.
30 hours of community work + 20 strokes on naked buttocks.
20 hours of community work + 30 strokes on naked buttocks.
30 strokes on naked buttocks only.
20 strokes on naked buttocks only.
Other form of punishment.
Case #4: A 15 years old boy was found guilty of destruction of property (damaged the bus stop). Which of the following is the most appropriate punishment?
30 hours of community work only.
20 hours of community work only.
30 hours of community work + 20 strokes on naked buttocks.
20 hours of community work + 30 strokes on naked buttocks.
30 strokes on naked buttocks only.
20 strokes on naked buttocks only.
Other form of punishment.
Thank you very much for participating. Feel freely to leave a comment.
I'll leave a comment.
I don't want to leave any comments.
This poll was created on 2017-04-14 13:14:15 by ProperPunishment