Which one is capable of lifting a bigger, heavier barbell overhead? HE? Or SHE?

AT THE GYM: When all other criteria are equal such as age, health, physical activity, etc., which one of the two, while reaching down to the mat, is capable of lifting a bigger, heavier barbell overhead than the other? A short fat girl standing 4-foot-9 and weighing 190 pounds? Or a tall skinny guy standing 6-foot-3 and weighing 130 pounds? (He towers over her by a foot and a half while she outweighs him by sixty pounds)