Judicial Corporal Punishment

I think judicial punishment like this could work for women, but not for men. i just dont think men get anything out of it, and i dont think it deters them. i think longer jail terms and community work for violent crimes work better for men.

women and girls respond to spanking punishments. i dont think it should be public. that could be abused. but a girl who commits a small offense should know that she would be belted in a back room, and that could change her behavior.

Hi Analee

Why do you not think that a good spanking would benefit males. I received corporal punishment growing up and certainly feel it was beneficial.

I think both young males and females would benefit. Why mess up their future life over some foolish youthful stunt with a jail/criminal record when a traditional butt whipping & some community service would accomplish correction.

As SSP notes, CP worked for him growing up as a male and did for me too and many boys I knew.

SSP & R.J.,

I might be wrong and you certainly could be right. I'm just going by how i was brought up. When i was growing up, i only knew that girls were spanked, and it never occurred to me that boys were too. But i can see how it might work with boys too, as children.

For adults, i would never think of spanking a man as punishment. But i think women need it sometimes. But i'm only going from my perspective and my relationships. Everyone certainly is different.

Thank you Analee

From my own experiences growing up boys and girls were treated equally, at least their bottoms were.! I think that is only fair