Welcome! Sign in to access your account. New user?

American Idol 5 Bests!

Results | Messages
Please make your decisions on who sang well on the given night, regardless of your favorite. Thanks!
Who sang the best on the Top 12 girls' night?
Mandisa: Never
Kellie Pickler: How Far
Becky O'Donohue: Because the Night
Ayla Brown: Reflection
Paris Bennett: Midnight Train to Georgia
Stevie Scott: To Where You Are
Brenna Gethers: You Are The Sunshine of My Life
Heather Cox: When You Tell Me That You Love Me
Melissa McGhee: When The Lights Go Down
Lisa Tucker: I Am Changing
Kinnik Sky: Get Here
Katharine McPhee: Since I Fell For You
Who sang the best on the Top 12 Guys' Night?
Patrick Hall: Come To My Window
David Radford: Crazy Little Thing Called Love
Bucky Convington: Simple Man
Will Makar: I Want You Back
Jose Penala: Reasons
Chris Daughtry: Wanted Dead or Alive
Kevin Covais: One Last Cry
Gedeon McKinney: Shout
Elliott Yamin: If You Really Love Me
Bobby Bennett Jr: Copacabana
Ace Young: Father Figure
Taylor Hicks: Levon
Who sang the best on the Top 10 Girls' night?
Katharine McPhee: All in Love is Fair
Kinnik Sky: Here for the Party
Lisa Tucker: Who's Loving You
Melissa McGhee: Why Haven't I Heard From You
Heather Cox: Hero
Brenna Gethers: Last Dance
Paris Bennett: Wind Beneath My Wings
Ayla Brown: I Want You to Need Me
Kellie Pickler: Something To Talk About
Mandisa: Cry
Who sang the best on the Top 10 Guys' night?
Taylor Hicks: Easy
Elliott Yamin: Moody's Mood For Love
Ace Young: If I'm Not Made For You
Gedeon McKinney: Change Is Gonna Come
Kevin Covais: I Heard It Through the Grapevine
Jose Penala: Overjoyed
Will Makar: Lady
Bucky Convington: The Thunder Rolls
David Radford: The Way You Look Tonight
Chris Daughtry: Hemorrage
Who sang the best on the Top 8 Girls' night?
Paris Bennett: Conga
Lisa Tucker: Here's Where I Stand
Melissa McGhee: What About Love
Kinnik Sky: If I Ain't Got You
Katharine McPhee: Think
Ayla Brown: Unwritten
Mandisa: I'm Every Woman
Kellie Pickler: I'm The Only One
Who sang the best on the Top 8 Guys' night?
Gedeon McKinney: When a Man Loves a Woman
Chris Daughtry: Broken
Kevin Covais: Vincent Starry Starry Night
Bucky Covington: Wave on Wave
Will Makar: How Sweet It Is to Be Loved By You
Taylor Hicks: Takin' it to the Streets
Elliott Yamin: Heaven
Ace Young: Butterflies
Who sang best on Stevie Wonder night? (Top 12)
Ace Young: Do I Do
Kellie Pickler: Blame it on the Sun
Elliott Yamin: Knocks Me Off My Feet
Mandisa: Don't You Worry Bout a Thing
Bucky Covington: Superstition
Melissa McGhee: Lately
Lisa Tucker: Signed Sealed Delivered
Kevin Covais: Part Time Lover
Katharine McPhee: Until You Come Back to Me
Taylor Hicks: Living for the City
Paris Bennett: All I Do
Chris Daughtry: Higher Ground
Who sang the best on '50s night?
Mandisa: I Don't Hurt Anymore
Bucky Convington: Oh Boy
Paris Bennett: Fever
Chris Daughtry: I Walk the Line
Katharine McPhee: Come Rain or Come Shine
Taylor Hicks: Not Fade Away
Lisa Tucker: Why Do Fools Fall in Love
Kevin Covais: When I Fall in Love
Elliott Yamin: Teach Me Tonight
Kellie Pickler: Walkin' After Midnight
Ace Young: In The Still of the Night
Who sang the best on Songs of the 21st Century night?
Lisa Tucker: Because of You
Kellie Pickler: Suds in the Bucket
Ace Young: Drops of Jupiter
Taylor Hicks: Trouble
Mandisa: Wanna Praise You
Chris Daughtry: What If
Katharine McPhee: The Voice Within
Bucky Covington: Real Good Man
Paris Bennett: Work It Out
Elliott Yamin: I Don't Want to Be
Who sang the best on Country night?
Taylor Hicks: Take Me Home, Country Roads
Mandisa: Any Man of Mine
Elliott Yamin: If Tomorrow Never Comes
Paris Bennett: How Do I Live Without You?
Ace Young: Tonight I Wanna Cry
Kellie Pickler: Fancy
Chris Daughtry: Making Memories Of Us
Katharine McPhee: Bringing Out The Elvis
Bucky Covington: Best I Ever Had
Who sang the best on Queen night?
Bucky Covington: Fat Bottomed Girls
Ace Young: We Will Rock You
Kellie Pickler: Bohemian Rhapsody
Chris Daughtry: Innuendo
Katharine McPhee: Who Wants to Live Forever
Elliott Yamin: Somebody to Love
Taylor Hicks: Crazy Little Thing Called Love
Paris Bennett: The Show Must Go On
Who sang the best on Songs from the Great American Songbook night?
Chris Daughtry: What A Wonderful World
Paris Bennett: These Foolish Things
Taylor Hicks: You Send Me
Elliott Yamin: It Had to Be You
Kellie Pickler: Bewitched, Bothered and Bewildered
Ace Young: That's All
Katharine McPhee: Someone To Watch Over Me
Who sang the best on Great Love Songs night?
Katharine McPhee: I Have Nothing
Elliott Yamin: A Song for You
Kellie Pickler: Unchained Melody
Paris Bennett: The Way We Were
Taylor Hicks: Just Once
Chris Daughtry: Have You Ever Really Loved a Woman?
Who sang the best in the first half of the Top 5 Night (Songs from the year you were born)?
Elliott Yamin: On Broadway
Paris Bennett: Kiss
Chris Daughtry: Renegade
Katharine McPhee: Against All Odds
Taylor Hicks: Play That Funky Music
Who sang the best in the second half of the Top 5 night (Billboard hits)?
Elliott Yamin: Home
Paris Bennett: Be Without You
Chris Daughtry: I Dare You
Katharine McPhee: Black Horse and the Cherry Tree
Taylor Hicks: Something
Who sang the best in the first half of Elvis night?
Taylor Hicks: Jailhouse Rock
Chris Daughtry: Suspicious Minds
Elliott Yamin: If I Can Dream
Katharine McPhee: Hound Dog/All Shook Up
Who sang the best in the second half of Elvis night?
Taylor Hicks: In The Ghetto
Chris Daughtry: A Little Less Conversation
Elliott Yamin: Trouble
Katharine McPhee: Can't Help Falling in Love
Who sang the best in Round 1 on the Top 3 night (Clive's Pick)?
Elliott Yamin: Open Arms
Katharine McPhee: I Believe I Can Fly
Taylor Hicks: Dancing In The Dark
Who sang the best in Round 2 on the Top 3 night (Judges' Choice)?
Elliott Yamin: What You Won't Do for Love
Katharine McPhee: Somewhere Over The Rainbow
Taylor Hicks: You Are So Beautiful
Who sang the best in Round 3 on the Top 3 night (Contestants' Choice)?
Elliott Yamin: I Believe to My Soul
Katharine McPhee: I Ain't Got Nothing But the Blues
Taylor Hicks: Try a Little Tenderness
Who sang the best in Round 1 of the Top 2 night?
Katharine McPhee: Black Horse and the Cherry Tree
Taylor Hicks: Living for the City
Who sang the best in Round 2 of the Top 2 night?
Katharine McPhee: Somewhere Over the Rainbow
Taylor Hicks: Levon
Who sang the best in Round 3 on the Top 2 night?
Katharine McPhee: My Destiny
Taylor Hicks: Do I Make You Proud
And last but not least, who is YOUR American Idol from Season 5?
Melissa McGhee
Kevin Covais
Lisa Tucker
Mandisa
Bucky Covington
Ace Young
Kellie Pickler
Paris Bennett
Chris Daughtry
Elliott Yamin
Katharine McPhee
Taylor Hicks
This poll was created on 2006-10-05 19:56:08 by PabloR