American Idol 5 Bests!
Who sang the best on the Top 12 girls' night?
| 6% (1) | Mandisa: Never | |
|---|---|---|
| 6% (1) | Kellie Pickler: How Far | |
| 0% (0) | Becky O'Donohue: Because the Night | |
| 6% (1) | Ayla Brown: Reflection | |
| 13% (2) | Paris Bennett: Midnight Train to Georgia | |
| 0% (0) | Stevie Scott: To Where You Are | |
| 0% (0) | Brenna Gethers: You Are The Sunshine of My Life | |
| 0% (0) | Heather Cox: When You Tell Me That You Love Me | |
| 6% (1) | Melissa McGhee: When The Lights Go Down | |
| 0% (0) | Lisa Tucker: I Am Changing | |
| 0% (0) | Kinnik Sky: Get Here | |
| 60% (9) | Katharine McPhee: Since I Fell For You |
15 voters have answered this question.
Who sang the best on the Top 12 Guys' Night?
| 0% (0) | Patrick Hall: Come To My Window | |
|---|---|---|
| 0% (0) | David Radford: Crazy Little Thing Called Love | |
| 8% (1) | Bucky Convington: Simple Man | |
| 0% (0) | Will Makar: I Want You Back | |
| 0% (0) | Jose Penala: Reasons | |
| 16% (2) | Chris Daughtry: Wanted Dead or Alive | |
| 0% (0) | Kevin Covais: One Last Cry | |
| 0% (0) | Gedeon McKinney: Shout | |
| 58% (7) | Elliott Yamin: If You Really Love Me | |
| 0% (0) | Bobby Bennett Jr: Copacabana | |
| 0% (0) | Ace Young: Father Figure | |
| 16% (2) | Taylor Hicks: Levon |
12 voters have answered this question.
Who sang the best on the Top 10 Girls' night?
| 53% (8) | Katharine McPhee: All in Love is Fair | |
|---|---|---|
| 0% (0) | Kinnik Sky: Here for the Party | |
| 0% (0) | Lisa Tucker: Who's Loving You | |
| 6% (1) | Melissa McGhee: Why Haven't I Heard From You | |
| 0% (0) | Heather Cox: Hero | |
| 0% (0) | Brenna Gethers: Last Dance | |
| 0% (0) | Paris Bennett: Wind Beneath My Wings | |
| 13% (2) | Ayla Brown: I Want You to Need Me | |
| 13% (2) | Kellie Pickler: Something To Talk About | |
| 13% (2) | Mandisa: Cry |
15 voters have answered this question.
Who sang the best on the Top 10 Guys' night?
| 9% (1) | Taylor Hicks: Easy | |
|---|---|---|
| 54% (6) | Elliott Yamin: Moody's Mood For Love | |
| 0% (0) | Ace Young: If I'm Not Made For You | |
| 0% (0) | Gedeon McKinney: Change Is Gonna Come | |
| 0% (0) | Kevin Covais: I Heard It Through the Grapevine | |
| 0% (0) | Jose Penala: Overjoyed | |
| 9% (1) | Will Makar: Lady | |
| 0% (0) | Bucky Convington: The Thunder Rolls | |
| 0% (0) | David Radford: The Way You Look Tonight | |
| 27% (3) | Chris Daughtry: Hemorrage |
11 voters have answered this question.
Who sang the best on the Top 8 Girls' night?
| 0% (0) | Paris Bennett: Conga | |
|---|---|---|
| 0% (0) | Lisa Tucker: Here's Where I Stand | |
| 0% (0) | Melissa McGhee: What About Love | |
| 0% (0) | Kinnik Sky: If I Ain't Got You | |
| 64% (9) | Katharine McPhee: Think | |
| 14% (2) | Ayla Brown: Unwritten | |
| 14% (2) | Mandisa: I'm Every Woman | |
| 7% (1) | Kellie Pickler: I'm The Only One |
14 voters have answered this question.
Who sang the best on the Top 8 Guys' night?
| 0% (0) | Gedeon McKinney: When a Man Loves a Woman | |
|---|---|---|
| 10% (1) | Chris Daughtry: Broken | |
| 0% (0) | Kevin Covais: Vincent Starry Starry Night | |
| 0% (0) | Bucky Covington: Wave on Wave | |
| 0% (0) | Will Makar: How Sweet It Is to Be Loved By You | |
| 30% (3) | Taylor Hicks: Takin' it to the Streets | |
| 60% (6) | Elliott Yamin: Heaven | |
| 0% (0) | Ace Young: Butterflies |
10 voters have answered this question.
Who sang best on Stevie Wonder night? (Top 12)
| 0% (0) | Ace Young: Do I Do | |
|---|---|---|
| 6% (1) | Kellie Pickler: Blame it on the Sun | |
| 25% (4) | Elliott Yamin: Knocks Me Off My Feet | |
| 0% (0) | Mandisa: Don't You Worry Bout a Thing | |
| 0% (0) | Bucky Covington: Superstition | |
| 0% (0) | Melissa McGhee: Lately | |
| 0% (0) | Lisa Tucker: Signed Sealed Delivered | |
| 0% (0) | Kevin Covais: Part Time Lover | |
| 56% (9) | Katharine McPhee: Until You Come Back to Me | |
| 12% (2) | Taylor Hicks: Living for the City | |
| 0% (0) | Paris Bennett: All I Do | |
| 0% (0) | Chris Daughtry: Higher Ground |
16 voters have answered this question.
Who sang the best on '50s night?
| 0% (0) | Mandisa: I Don't Hurt Anymore | |
|---|---|---|
| 0% (0) | Bucky Convington: Oh Boy | |
| 6% (1) | Paris Bennett: Fever | |
| 6% (1) | Chris Daughtry: I Walk the Line | |
| 43% (7) | Katharine McPhee: Come Rain or Come Shine | |
| 6% (1) | Taylor Hicks: Not Fade Away | |
| 0% (0) | Lisa Tucker: Why Do Fools Fall in Love | |
| 6% (1) | Kevin Covais: When I Fall in Love | |
| 25% (4) | Elliott Yamin: Teach Me Tonight | |
| 6% (1) | Kellie Pickler: Walkin' After Midnight | |
| 0% (0) | Ace Young: In The Still of the Night |
16 voters have answered this question.
Who sang the best on Songs of the 21st Century night?
| 0% (0) | Lisa Tucker: Because of You | |
|---|---|---|
| 6% (1) | Kellie Pickler: Suds in the Bucket | |
| 0% (0) | Ace Young: Drops of Jupiter | |
| 6% (1) | Taylor Hicks: Trouble | |
| 0% (0) | Mandisa: Wanna Praise You | |
| 0% (0) | Chris Daughtry: What If | |
| 37% (6) | Katharine McPhee: The Voice Within | |
| 0% (0) | Bucky Covington: Real Good Man | |
| 12% (2) | Paris Bennett: Work It Out | |
| 37% (6) | Elliott Yamin: I Don't Want to Be |
16 voters have answered this question.
Who sang the best on Country night?
| 6% (1) | Taylor Hicks: Take Me Home, Country Roads | |
|---|---|---|
| 0% (0) | Mandisa: Any Man of Mine | |
| 25% (4) | Elliott Yamin: If Tomorrow Never Comes | |
| 6% (1) | Paris Bennett: How Do I Live Without You? | |
| 6% (1) | Ace Young: Tonight I Wanna Cry | |
| 6% (1) | Kellie Pickler: Fancy | |
| 0% (0) | Chris Daughtry: Making Memories Of Us | |
| 50% (8) | Katharine McPhee: Bringing Out The Elvis | |
| 0% (0) | Bucky Covington: Best I Ever Had |
16 voters have answered this question.
Who sang the best on Queen night?
| 0% (0) | Bucky Covington: Fat Bottomed Girls | |
|---|---|---|
| 5% (1) | Ace Young: We Will Rock You | |
| 11% (2) | Kellie Pickler: Bohemian Rhapsody | |
| 0% (0) | Chris Daughtry: Innuendo | |
| 35% (6) | Katharine McPhee: Who Wants to Live Forever | |
| 41% (7) | Elliott Yamin: Somebody to Love | |
| 5% (1) | Taylor Hicks: Crazy Little Thing Called Love | |
| 0% (0) | Paris Bennett: The Show Must Go On |
17 voters have answered this question.
Who sang the best on Songs from the Great American Songbook night?
| 0% (0) | Chris Daughtry: What A Wonderful World | |
|---|---|---|
| 0% (0) | Paris Bennett: These Foolish Things | |
| 12% (2) | Taylor Hicks: You Send Me | |
| 25% (4) | Elliott Yamin: It Had to Be You | |
| 6% (1) | Kellie Pickler: Bewitched, Bothered and Bewildered | |
| 0% (0) | Ace Young: That's All | |
| 56% (9) | Katharine McPhee: Someone To Watch Over Me |
16 voters have answered this question.
Who sang the best on Great Love Songs night?
| 33% (6) | Katharine McPhee: I Have Nothing | |
|---|---|---|
| 38% (7) | Elliott Yamin: A Song for You | |
| 5% (1) | Kellie Pickler: Unchained Melody | |
| 0% (0) | Paris Bennett: The Way We Were | |
| 5% (1) | Taylor Hicks: Just Once | |
| 16% (3) | Chris Daughtry: Have You Ever Really Loved a Woman? |
18 voters have answered this question.
Who sang the best in the first half of the Top 5 Night (Songs from the year you were born)?
| 40% (6) | Elliott Yamin: On Broadway | |
|---|---|---|
| 6% (1) | Paris Bennett: Kiss | |
| 13% (2) | Chris Daughtry: Renegade | |
| 33% (5) | Katharine McPhee: Against All Odds | |
| 6% (1) | Taylor Hicks: Play That Funky Music |
15 voters have answered this question.
Who sang the best in the second half of the Top 5 night (Billboard hits)?
| 25% (4) | Elliott Yamin: Home | |
|---|---|---|
| 0% (0) | Paris Bennett: Be Without You | |
| 6% (1) | Chris Daughtry: I Dare You | |
| 56% (9) | Katharine McPhee: Black Horse and the Cherry Tree | |
| 12% (2) | Taylor Hicks: Something |
16 voters have answered this question.
Who sang the best in the first half of Elvis night?
| 6% (1) | Taylor Hicks: Jailhouse Rock | |
|---|---|---|
| 18% (3) | Chris Daughtry: Suspicious Minds | |
| 37% (6) | Elliott Yamin: If I Can Dream | |
| 37% (6) | Katharine McPhee: Hound Dog/All Shook Up |
16 voters have answered this question.
Who sang the best in the second half of Elvis night?
| 18% (3) | Taylor Hicks: In The Ghetto | |
|---|---|---|
| 6% (1) | Chris Daughtry: A Little Less Conversation | |
| 31% (5) | Elliott Yamin: Trouble | |
| 43% (7) | Katharine McPhee: Can't Help Falling in Love |
16 voters have answered this question.
Who sang the best in Round 1 on the Top 3 night (Clive's Pick)?
| 25% (4) | Elliott Yamin: Open Arms | |
|---|---|---|
| 62% (10) | Katharine McPhee: I Believe I Can Fly | |
| 12% (2) | Taylor Hicks: Dancing In The Dark |
16 voters have answered this question.
Who sang the best in Round 2 on the Top 3 night (Judges' Choice)?
| 25% (4) | Elliott Yamin: What You Won't Do for Love | |
|---|---|---|
| 68% (11) | Katharine McPhee: Somewhere Over The Rainbow | |
| 6% (1) | Taylor Hicks: You Are So Beautiful |
16 voters have answered this question.
Who sang the best in Round 3 on the Top 3 night (Contestants' Choice)?
| 33% (5) | Elliott Yamin: I Believe to My Soul | |
|---|---|---|
| 53% (8) | Katharine McPhee: I Ain't Got Nothing But the Blues | |
| 13% (2) | Taylor Hicks: Try a Little Tenderness |
15 voters have answered this question.
Who sang the best in Round 1 of the Top 2 night?
| 75% (9) | Katharine McPhee: Black Horse and the Cherry Tree | |
|---|---|---|
| 25% (3) | Taylor Hicks: Living for the City |
12 voters have answered this question.
Who sang the best in Round 2 of the Top 2 night?
| 92% (12) | Katharine McPhee: Somewhere Over the Rainbow | |
|---|---|---|
| 7% (1) | Taylor Hicks: Levon |
13 voters have answered this question.
Who sang the best in Round 3 on the Top 2 night?
| 69% (9) | Katharine McPhee: My Destiny | |
|---|---|---|
| 30% (4) | Taylor Hicks: Do I Make You Proud |
13 voters have answered this question.
And last but not least, who is YOUR American Idol from Season 5?
| 0% (0) | Melissa McGhee | |
|---|---|---|
| 0% (0) | Kevin Covais | |
| 0% (0) | Lisa Tucker | |
| 0% (0) | Mandisa | |
| 0% (0) | Bucky Covington | |
| 0% (0) | Ace Young | |
| 5% (1) | Kellie Pickler | |
| 0% (0) | Paris Bennett | |
| 5% (1) | Chris Daughtry | |
| 26% (5) | Elliott Yamin | |
| 47% (9) | Katharine McPhee | |
| 15% (3) | Taylor Hicks |
19 voters have answered this question.
